What happened

On September 8, 2015, a South Carolina federal court entered a consent decree in an EEOC race-discrimination lawsuit against BMW Manufacturing Co., LLC, the Spartanburg plant operator (parent BMW is headquartered in Munich). EEOC alleged that after BMW switched logistics contractors in 2008, a criminal-conviction screen—without regard to how old the conviction was or whether it was a misdemeanor or felony—disqualified incumbents at a disproportionate rate for African-Americans. The complaint figures EEOC published: about 100 incumbents failed the screen; about 80 percent of those disqualified were Black; EEOC sought relief for 56 African-Americans who lost the jobs. Those are allegations in the agency’s pleading, not a trial verdict. EEOC said BMW had already changed the guidelines.

BMW agreed to pay $1.6 million and to offer jobs to the discharged workers in the suit and to up to 90 African-American applicants turned away under the old screen, plus training and monitoring. EEOC called it a resolution of the lawsuit and related charges. A consent decree is a settlement. It is not an admission of liability.

The Cookout read

Mixed. A federal case about Black logistics workers screened out of a South Carolina auto plant is the file. The dollars and the job offers are labeled as what the decree required. This file will not treat complaint percentages as a jury’s math, or the check as proof the allegations were either fully proved or fully walked back.